How to Find a Great Wedding DJ in NJ (From Someone Who Used to Be One)
Let me drop a little truth bomb on you: before I was running around photographing love stories like it was my damn calling, I spent a solid 10 years behind the decks as a wedding DJ. Yup. That was my original in into this wild wedding industry and while I’ve traded the turntables for cameras, I still know what makes a good DJ and what makes a great one.
So if you're planning your New Jersey wedding and you want the party to actually feel like a party (not a middle school dance with awkward song transitions), listen up. Here's how to find a wedding DJ who won't kill the vibe.
All Rights Reserved @ Stefan Lane Creative Photography
1. Decide What Kind of DJ You Want
Do you want someone who curates the soundtrack to your night like a smooth professional, reading the crowd and keeping the floor packed without a single “Cha Cha Slide” in sight? Or do you want an emcee who’s interactive, on the mic hyping up your cousins, maybe running some games or handling intros with big energy?
There’s no right or wrong here… it’s about your vibe. But knowing what you're looking for helps narrow the field fast.
Pro Tip: If you’re planning a more intimate or moody/artful wedding, you probably don’t want DJ Shouty McMicrophone. But if your crowd needs some extra juice to get going, a personality-forward DJ could be your secret weapon.
2. Ask About Their Music Style (And How They Handle Requests)
A good DJ listens to you. They ask what kind of music you love, what to avoid, and how you want the flow of the night to go. A great DJ? They know how to take your taste and your guest list and weave it into a night that feels effortless and electric.
If your DJ won’t take the time to understand your music preferences, or if they scoff when you say “no line dances,” move on. You’re not hiring a club DJ here, you want someone who can blend professionalism with personal taste.
3. Watch Out for the “Package Deal” Trap
Some NJ wedding venues will try to upsell you with a “DJ included” package. And listen, sometimes those DJs are solid, but often they’re just whoever was cheapest for the venue to contract. You deserve better than background noise.
Always meet your DJ in person (or Zoom, if you must). Ask to see footage from actual weddings, not just polished promo reels. You want to see real dance floors, real crowds, real energy.
4. Don’t Just Look at Gear… Look at Experience
Any clown can show up with flashy uplighting and a smoke machine. But none of that matters if the DJ can’t read a crowd or build a set list with flow. The best NJ wedding DJs are part entertainer, part music nerd, part event wrangler. They've seen it all… drunk uncles requesting death metal, chaotic timelines, busted power strips… and they know how to roll with it.
5. Trust Your Gut (And Their Reviews)
Check reviews, sure… but also trust your instincts when you talk to them. If they talk over you or brush off your ideas, hell no. You’re hiring a collaborator, not a wedding dictator.
Ask them:
What’s your mixing style?
How do you handle guest requests?
How do you keep things flowing if dinner runs late?
Do you bring backup gear?
If they hesitate or give vague answers, keep shopping.
All Rights Reserved @ Stefan Lane Creative Photography
Final Thoughts
A great DJ doesn’t just press play… they set the tone for your entire night. From the first dance to the last shot of whiskey, the music shapes the energy. So don’t settle for “meh” because your cousin’s neighbor has a laptop and a Spotify account. Find someone who gets it, and your guests will be talking about your wedding for years.
Need help finding the right fit? Shoot me a message… I may not be spinning anymore, but I still keep tabs on who’s out there doing it right and I’ve got the hookup.